25 Toughest Companies To Interview With
How many uses for a brick could you come up with in a minute? Now imagine that you're being interviewed for a job that you badly want and have just been asked that question. That's only the tip of what it's like trying to get your foot in the door at the 25 most difficult companies to interview with.
Each year, job information site Glassdoor runs an extensive analysis on users' ratings of their job interviews and picks the 25 companies known for the most difficult interviews.
The data came from 170,000 reviews of interviews that users had gone on. The site users rate the difficulty, whether the experience was positive or negative, how many days the process ran, and sample questions.
The question about a brick -- actually a common question to test someone's creativity -- was used at semiconductor company Nvidia, No. 20 on the list. That's right, it can get much tougher.
Glassdoor has compiled this list for the last three years and each time consulting firm McKinsey & Company was at the top, with an average difficulty rating of 3.9 out of 5. The full interview process takes about 39 days, with 77 percent of the interviewees reporting a positive experience and 12 percent, a negative one. The second and third toughest were Thoughtworks and Boston Consulting Group.
Out of the top 25, Paycom had the highest percentage of negative experiences, compared to the average of 13 percent, according to Glassdoor. The most popular companies, based on positive experiences, were Rolls-Royce and Avaya, which tied at 86 percent. The average of positive experiences was 52 percent.
Although the average interview process for all companies rated on Glassdoor was 16 days, some of the difficulty for the top 25 may be how long it takes to get through the process. The average for them was just over 31 days. The longest were at Teach for America (55 days), Procter & Gamble (50 days), and Rolls-Royce (46 days).
Here come the questions: A business analyst candidate interviewing at McKinsey got the question, "How would you calculate the annual carbon emissions from electric versus gas vehicles in the EU?" The easy answer would seem to be that electric vehicles don't emit carbon because they don't burn fuel or have exhaust. However, the electric power has to be generated somehow, and that will involve some amount of emissions. (Non-profit International Council on Clean Transportation wrote a 24-page paper trying to answer that question.)
Many tough questions, such as "describe a time when you had to do something you didn't want to do" (Procter & Gamble brand manager interview) or "what kind of people do you dislike the most?" (Stryker sales representative interview) are intended to reveal something about the character of the person being interviewed. Others, like estimating the revenue from ticket sales to the 2012 Olympics (Bain & Company business analyst interview), are intended to see how a person thinks and approaches problems. Some measure specific job knowledge and skillsets.
Happily, the days of the gotcha trick question may have started to wane. This was something that was once synonymous with Google. But the company realized that "brainteasers are a waste of time," as Laszlo Bock, senior vice president of people operations at Google, told The New York Times.
From Google's lips to interviewers' ears.
How many golf balls can you fit into an airplane? How many gas stations in Manhattan? A complete waste of time. They don't predict anything. They serve primarily to make the interviewer feel smart.
Erik Sherman is a widely published writer and editor who also does select ghosting and corporate work. Follow him on Twitter at @ErikSherman