You are here: Jobs > Articles & News > Emergency Dispatcher Not The First To Be Fired Over 4-Minute Delay

Emergency Dispatcher Not The First To Be Fired Over 4-Minute Delay

By Claire Gordon , Posted Jan 27th 2012 @ 10:00AM

Text Size A A A


emergency dispatcher fired delayAn emergency dispatcher in Licking County, Ohio, is battling to get his job back after being fired in December over a four-minute delay in alerting firefighters to a burning home. Matt Wheeler did send firefighters to the home where a man was trapped inside, but apparently not fast enough for his employer, reports TV station WBNS in central Ohio.

It's stressful being on either side of a 911 call. Emergency dispatchers can't afford a five-minute daydream. A careless keystroke or a mental blip can end a person's life. While that didn't happen in this case, Wheeler already had three suspensions and two reprimands over his five-year career, so Licking County officials decided to fire him. His union, The Communications Workers of America, has filed a grievance on his behalf.

But delays can kill. A woman died in August 2008 from a blood clot in her lungs, after a 911 operator sent emergency crews to the wrong address. The operator misheard Dukes, who was struggling to breathe, and sent help to Wells Street, north of Atlanta, instead of Wales Drive, in Atlanta proper. Operators are supposed to determine the cell tower from where the telephone signal is coming from, and because of the error, it took 25 minutes for help to finally reach Dukes. The dispatcher was fired.

In San Antonio, Texas, the problem was thornier, because so many streets have nearly identical names. The computer-aided dispatch system there couldn't always differentiate between them, and an error in December 2010 sent firefighters responding to a house fire to the opposite side of town. (The elderly couple who resided at the house were fine, but in the 19 minutes it took for help to arrive, their home was destroyed). Firefighters warned that it was only a matter of time before this problem caused loss of life.

Controversy erupted over the behavior of another dispatcher in May 2008, following the murder of a University of Wisconsin-Madison student, Brittany Zimmerman. The 21-year-old had called 911 before she was stabbed and beaten to death in her apartment, but the call was disconnected. The operator didn't hear anything that made her think it was emergency, so she moved on to another call. Critics said it should have prompted a police response, or at least a call back.

This incident shows the great stakes that 911 operators cope with every day. They need to work with lightning speed and absolute accuracy, but also a sensitivity to what could be an emergency, when the clues are unclear. An error on one side can waste the precious time of emergency responders. An error on the other can cost a person's life.



Next: Florida Employer Found Guilty For Firing Woman Over Jury Duty



Don't Miss: Companies Hiring Now



Stories from 24/7 Wall St.

Claire Gordon

Claire Gordon

Claire Gordon has contributed to Slate's DoubleX, the Huffington Post, and the book Prisons: Current Controversies. While an undergraduate at Yale University and a research fellow at Yale graduate school, she spoke on panels at Yale and Cornell, and reported from Cairo, Tokyo, and Berlin. Follow Claire on Twitter.

more...

Add a Comment

*0 / 3000 Character Maximum

157 Comments

Filter by:
adam646l

lazy slob

January 30 2012 at 6:31 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Erica

Nope. You shouldn't get your job back. " Wheeler already had three suspensions and two reprimands over his five-year career" means that you are not good at a job that holds peoples' lives in your hands. Find another line of work. It sounds like McD's is at about your efficiency level.

January 30 2012 at 6:19 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Mark

Why do dispatchers ask so many stupid questions. Most of their calls that come in are a waste of time.
They sit around and gossipe about people's problems. Most are overweight and don't have a clue about
what is really going on. Why can't they just make it short and to the point. Majority seem like their writing a book.

January 30 2012 at 4:35 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
hubigspies

Hmmm. Three suspensions and two reprimands in only 5 years. If he were a lawyer, he would have been disbarred for life. Notably, the article does not include what happened to the man trapped inside the burning home but his fella is clearly not suited for that job.

January 30 2012 at 3:11 AM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
joeheyjoe

I understand that a 911 dispatcher has a stressful and difficult job, but this guy deserves to be fired. Just because the job is tough doesn't mean it's ok to screw up. People's lives depend on these dispatchers and if they can't keep up with the demands of the job, then they need to step down and be replaced by someone that can. No one is forcing anyone to take these jobs. If they find it to be too overwhelming, it's better for them to find another job than to end up messing up and costing someone their life. Thank you to all the dispatchers out there that are able to perform this job, it is greatly appreciated.

January 30 2012 at 3:01 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
Nicole

I used to work as a Security Dispatcher, we dispatched on house and business alarms of various natures. One night I dispatched out a alarm at a local business, the Call taker at the call center for the police let the alarm sit on the screen for 40 mins, before the PD were dispatched, by that time our guard and the store owner were onsite and in the store....the burg's ended up with 150k worth of jewelry.

January 30 2012 at 2:48 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
Medic538

#1 we weren't there. Unless you've done the job don't make judgement until all the facts are out. I have worked as a full time Medic for 18 years. I have been in the dispatch center, and believe me, you wouldn't want to sit there for 12 hours handling one call after another.

A four minute delay? Was he on another call? Maybe his system requires him to switch between land lines and radio. He maybe dealing with multiple fire alarms + dozens of ambulance runs at the same time. Yes, it happens FOR HOURS on end. Every move an ambulance makes ENROUTE / ON SCENE, etc is radioed in. He has to respond and document the system. You have no idea what his responsibilities are, or what his job entails. Maybe he is a good employee who works for incompetent a-holes who never deserved their promotions let alone their jobs.

January 30 2012 at 1:18 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Medic538's comment
shell

AMEN! at least someone here isn't a zombie slave to the media and can realize that there's more to the job then just picking up the phone. Seriously, how many times EVERY DAY do "normal" people make mistakes in their jobs? yes, of course you want the dispatcher to be perfect, but really.. REALLY? they're human. They have kids that are sick, they have homes and cars that are being re-posessed, they have everyday LIFE going on around them and you ungrateful people screaming at them because someone is blocking your driveway and you seem to think it's an emergancy. The next time you decide to point fingers, take a look in the mirror and ask yourself when what the last time you waited to start the project your boss asked because you were playing farmville @ work.

January 31 2012 at 3:30 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
idontcare761

When you call , I understand it's an emergency , but , you need to calm down long enough to tell them an address if you are on a cell phone and what is happening so they know who to send where. You would be surprised at some of the calls that people make , they are unintelligible and you can't blame the 911 dispatcher for not understanding , no one would be able to. Thankfully , they can get a physical address off of a landline phone , just not a cell phone. So please , for your own sakes , Try to hang in there and calmly state your need. I know in an emergency it's hard..but the call will go smoother and quicker.

January 30 2012 at 12:48 AM Report abuse -1 rate up rate down Reply
Richard

The Communications Workers of America, has filed a grievance on his behalf.

The Man deserved to lose his job. What part of an emergency call don't they get??

January 30 2012 at 12:33 AM Report abuse +3 rate up rate down Reply
1 reply to Richard's comment
T REXX

CWA FINE BUNCH OF SLACKERS THEMSELVES SEE HOW LONG THEY STAYED OUT ON STRIKE..LOL... COLLECT THE DUES AND FLUSH EVERYTHING ELSE

January 30 2012 at 5:52 AM Report abuse rate up rate down Reply
idontcare761

My son is a 911 dispatcher. It's an extremely stressful job , dealing with anything and everything you can imagine. Just last week he got a call from a woman who killed her husband and was going to kill herself. He got her address and the woman hung up. He had already patched the police in on the call as soon as she said she killed him , and he tried a call back but got no answer. By the time the police got there , maybe 4 minutes from the time she called , she had shot herself as well. Then there was the other call he got a day or 2 later , a guy called , angry at the world , mostly his girlfriend , but at the world as well. He called a bomb threat in , said he built a bomb and it was going to go off and kill everyone in this building , my son traced the call and patched it in while he kept the guy talking , asking what the bomb was made if , did it have a timer , etc. The police got there while the guy was still on the phone talking to my son. No , there wasn't a bomb , he was just mad and needed attention apparently. Of all the cities in this area , only 1 handles their own calls. This is a major metropolitan area and between all the cities and counties included in the 911 area , there is a fair share of crime and crazy out there. It's a tough job , most people don't make it through training.

January 30 2012 at 12:29 AM Report abuse +2 rate up rate down Reply
ADVERTISEMENT

Search Jobs

Search Articles

Top Companies Hiring

Feb. 19 - Feb. 25

Need a Job? See what companies added new job openings this week.


View Top 10 Companies Hiring

What's Hot on AOL Jobs

More on AOL Jobs

 
 
Office Humor 

Take a break from the day-to-day and enjoy some office antics.

 
 
Confessions   

Find out what it's like to work various jobs, first hand.

 
 
Resume Rescue  

See how resumes have been revamped for maximum impact.

 
 
New Grads  

From internships to first jobs, start out on the right foot!

 
 
Working Parents   

It can be tough to juggle a career and a family. We're here to help.

 
 
Undercover Boss  

We interview the bosses featured on CBS' hit show.