By Anne Fisher
Dear Annie: I'm a week away from my 54th birthday and, man, am I getting discouraged. After being laid off from a fairly senior job in May, I've spent the past few months networking nonstop, and managed to get three interviews. One interviewer never got back to me at all, and the other two both said I am overqualified for the jobs they have to offer.
I suspect that "overqualified" is corporate code for "old and expensive," so I tried to explain that I am more than willing to take a step or two down in position and salary (both my kids are out of college now, and our mortgage is almost paid off), but I still hit a brick wall. How does one get around being seen as "overqualified"? --Highly Experienced
Dear Experienced: A new ExecuNet survey suggests you aren't the only one who suspects your age may be working against you. Fully 91% of 258 headhunters in a recent poll said they believe age becomes "a significant factor in a hiring decision" when a candidate is over 50.
Interestingly, though, fewer than half (41%) of 4,680 over-50 job seekers themselves ExecuNet polled in the same survey think their age has hurt their chances of being hired.
Perhaps that's because, while age bias certainly exists, "there is far less of it than many people fear," says Rob Saam, a senior vice president who is head of the career transition practice at outplacement giant Lee Hecht Harrison. "Human resources professionals and hiring managers are well aware of all the research showing that someone 50 or older is likely to stay longer, be more dedicated, and be absent less than the average 30-year-old."
So how do you find employers who agree? Whatever you do, don't stop networking, advises Saam. "Otherwise, on job boards for instance, you're relying on your résumé alone," he says. "That isn't nearly as effective. If someone sees, not words on a page, but a vibrant, energetic person sitting across the table from them, age becomes much less of an issue."
Networking also gives you an advantage over younger candidates, says Lauryn Franzoni, executive director of national career-development network ExecuNet. "Your years of experience also mean you have more contacts to tap who are likely to be in a position to help you get your foot in the door," she says. "Keep moving on until you find connections and organizations who see your value."
Let's assume you were vibrant, energetic, and positive as all get-out during your three interviews, to no avail.
The problem, in interviewers' eyes, might not be pay or age bias so much as the fact that you recently left a "fairly senior" job, as you put it, says Erik Sorenson, CEO of career site Vault.com. He recommends thinking hard about why a step down in rank really is okay with you, and then talking about that.
"For example, a less senior job may well be a less stressful job, and that may hold a lot of appeal for you at this point," Sorenson says. "But you have to be sincere, because if you say something like that and you don't really mean it, the interviewer will sense your ambivalence and see trouble ahead."
He also suggests cultivating a certain humility, if you haven't already. "Don't forget there is a delicate balance here. You don't want to be seen as gunning for the hiring manager's job," he says. "Talk about how much you want to be part of a team and make a contribution. You might also mention your willingness to mentor others. Another strong point would be enthusiasm about taking on special projects. The point is, you want to convey that you have no hang-ups about not being the boss anymore."
Meanwhile, Sorensen adds: "You were smart to mention that you're amenable to a pay cut because your kids are grown. Legally, employers can't ask you things like how many kids you have or how old they are, so if that whole area of your life is relevant to your career plans now, you have to be the one to bring it up."
You don't mention whether you've been job hunting in the same industry, or the same size companies, as you worked in before. Sorenson has noticed that over-50 job seekers often find a warmer reception in a business that is related to their old field but not actually in it, or in smaller companies where long experience may be relatively rare and thus more valued.
"Startups in particular often lack the kind of long-range perspective and strategic insights that older managers can bring," he notes. "You may need to get a little bit out of your comfort zone, and cast your net a bit wider, to find the right opportunity."
Next: How to Dumb Down Your Resume To Get a Job >>
See Also:
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 9)
One additional suggestion is to try and find your way to a job that is a fit with your strengths and passions. One reason employers are so weary of over-qualified employees is that they are often the first to complain when the economy comes back, or the first to leave.
ReplyIf you can sell yourself wanting the job because it is a great fit for your strengths and passions, and thus it will engage you more (even if lower pay), they may buy it. Strengths and passions are really the key to successful career choices.
Rick Smith
The Leap
I have also found that some employers are "afraid" that someone who is older and more experienced won't do the job in the way that the new employer wants it to be done! I have been told this in the past, as long ago as when I was just entering my 30's (too many years ago to mention
;-p). I often make a point of letting people know that I am ALWAYS willing to learn, do whatever they want done their way. I might make suggestions and IF they do not like those suggestions, fine, their way is MY way then.
rick, what publication do you write for?
your observations (in my opinion)...right on the money.
I was just turned down for an ad sales position and given the reason that I was not a good match. Not a good match for a large community magazine group that direct mails the magazine? I've sold ads for a direct mail company, a magazine and sold for a large community newspaper group and was manager of three of the newspapers.
I am 56. Hate to say this, but if I was 10-20 years younger, I am sure I would have been hired on the spot.
I guess we are looking a two different things what I saw was NO JOB OR JOB OFFER IT WAS TWITTER. wHAT THE H... WAS THAT
ReplyI GOT LAID OFF IN MY 50'S AND HAVE NOT BE ABLE TO FIND A JOB JUST PART TIME, AND HERE I AM AT 68 AND STILL NO JOB AND SHE PUTS STUFF LIKE THAT ON. YES I AM P......
Hi Jaunita
Are you still looking to make some extra money per month?If you are I will help,contact me at wealthisgoodhealth@gmail.com
Jonathan
Been there,done that.They only take your money and send you a kid that you can do nothing with.....
ReplyDimitrios: they gave you a kid? how old was the kid? was he/she educated at all, e.g. reads and writes? was the kid an orphan? do the kids parents know that their kid was given to an American for doing business? that is amazing. we have been waiting to adopt for years. i might try this. thanks!
Hi Dimitrios,
Are you still looking to make some extra money per month?If you are I will help,contact me at wealthisgoodhealth@gmail.com
Jonathan
I have been unemployeed for over a year. I agree with everyone being over 50 does not help. I have taken a step 'sideways'. I am having luck getting interviews where my job of 3o years seems to be helping. I'm not sure if all job catagories can benefit from this; what harm is there in trying.
ReplyHi Kathahern,
Are you still looking to make some extra money per month?If you are I will help,contact me at wealthisgoodhealth@gmail.com
Jonathan
Good luck to you. No matter what employers say, if they sense you're older than 50 your resume goes on the "ignore" pile. I was fortunate to have a skill that people contract for, but as far as full-time jobs, employers will just ignore you. Remember, you have 40-year-olds and younger making many employment decisions. How badly do you think they want to supervise people older than they are? Even the AARP discriminates based on age. How's THAT for an insult?
ReplyIf I can ask; what do you do, and what did you have to pay for training?
ReplyAnother option, depending on your field, is taking an on-call, PRN, or consultant position. The company cangive you 40 hours. Not being a FT employee they are not obilgated to offer benefits. I've got my a possibility for that. I can't wait for these possibilities to grow.
ReplyI've been in and out of work since 09/06. Just when I seem to be getting anywhere, the employment rug gets yanked out from under me once again. I am now unable to pay off my credit card debt and am forced to seek food stamps just to keep food on the table.If I hear back from any of the applications I've submitted it is usually - sorry, you don't fit our needs. I guess they're afraid I'll work for a couple of years and then retire. I just want to work.
ReplyAll the bottom feeders are out praying on people in need becareful of all the scams and pyramid schemes out there !!
ReplyMid Sixties....and after finding dead end, very low paying jobs I just took my social security and decided to become self employed. NO ONE will hire you at 65...no matter how sucessful you were or how much you know. WHY? Look across the table at the person doing the interviewing...You are looking in the face of your son or daughter..sometimes you grandkid! And they don't hire mom,dad or their grandparent. This last round of unemployment has been the kiss of death.
ReplyHi Shar,
Are you looking to make some extra money per month?If you are I will help,contact me at wealthisgoodhealth@gmail.com
Jonathan
Beware--no business that charges you ANYTHING is a legitimate opportunity. There are a few out there that are real home based businesses that don't charge. Most of the ones I have seen are generally taking complaint calls by phone and doesn't pay much. One is called Westathome.com There are a few hotels that have reservationists at their own home though you may have to go to their home base for training.One is Hilton. Do some searching on the internet, but don't pay ANYTHING or it's a scam.
ReplyHi Chase,
I maybe wasting my time because you have had a bad experience,but don't pre-judge .Are you still looking to make some extra money per month?If you are I will help,contact me at wealthisgoodhealth@gmail.com
Jonathan