The 'Never Specify a Salary' Myth

Posted Apr 22nd 2009 2:13PM

Don't believe the adage about not disclosing your salary requirements in a job interview. But it's best to speak up in the second interview

By Liz Ryan

Dear Liz,

I've always heard that it's best not to say anything about salary when you're interviewing for a job. Whoever mentions a number first has the disadvantage. I just don't want to waste my time on interview processes where the salary is too low for my background. How do I navigate that?

Thanks,
Bradley

Find a Job

Search by Company | Search by Industry

Dear Bradley,

That old notion of keeping mum about salary during an interview process is bad advice. If you keep quiet about your salary requirements throughout the whole process, here's what happens: The company makes you an offer, and the offer is ungodly low. Now, you can't say, "If you want to get me, you'll have to drastically improve that offer." O.K., you can say that, but you've already put yourself at a huge disadvantage by letting the conversation go on for so long without mentioning your salary requirements. It was your job to do that, and you didn't speak.

Getting an offer to a candidate is a big deal in the corporate world. Three or five or 14 people may have been involved in approving that offer, including people in your own future department, Human Resources, Finance, and who knows where else. Once the offer is on paper (or in an electronic document -- same thing), it's set in stone as far the company is concerned.

It's like moving mountains to get that offer adjusted after the fact. You can't rely on the offer coming in close enough to your salary mark. You've got to let the hiring manager know what you expect to earn at your next job before anybody at the company you hope to work for starts talking to anybody else about offering you a job.

The best time to bring up the salary topic is at the second interview. It's not appropriate to do that at a first interview, because you don't even know at that early stage whether the company is interested in you. If you don't want to make the trip for a second interview before making sure your salary is in the ballpark, ask the person who calls you or writes to you to schedule the second interview, "Should we talk beforehand to get synched up on our respective salary expectations?"

Ignoring Phantom Losses

At this point, whether you communicate via e-mail or over the phone, you're going to have to share a number. You can get that number online at Payscale.com, or get it from a headhunter buddy, or from your own gut and experience. The last thing you need to worry about is the prospect of leaving money on the table by naming too low a figure. Companies are not making overly generous job offers to anyone. Get the job at a decent salary. Don't worry about a phantom five thousand dollars you imagine you might have given up by naming too conservative a salary level.

Now, if you name your number and the hiring manager blanches, you'll know that he or she wasn't expecting to pay anyone that much. That's not necessarily a problem. You're unlikely to be tossed out of the running for your "extravagant" salary requirement. The company will merely tell you, "That's not in our range, but if you could see your way to accepting this job at $20,000 less, we should keep talking." Then, of course, you have a decision to make.

Having a job is better than not having one, but you will have to make your own decision about your salary floor. If you can't live on the salary you're being offered and believe that someone else will pay you more, you can pass on the job offer and keep looking. You could even talk to the employer about filling in as a contractor for them while they continue their search.

Whatever you do, Bradley, don't stay silent throughout the whole interview process in the mistaken belief that He Who Speaks First Loses. That couldn't be more wrong in this landscape. You've got to name your price, and you've got to do your research in order to be able to price your background and skills fairly.

Best, Liz

Next: Best Big Cities for Jobs

Liz Ryan is an expert on the new-millennium workplace and a former Fortune 500 HR executive.

Gallery: Top 10 Companies Hiring Now

Find a Job

Search by Company | Search by Industry

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)

Apr 22nd 2009 @ 2:53PM Julie

Tell me what kind of salary you are looking for - what's your dream? Email me at julie@whynotnetworkmarketing.net and check out my FREE TIPS website: www.whynotnetworkmarketing.net

Julie

%u2193 %u2191 report

Apr 28th 2009 @ 10:02PM Myro

I had an interview and felt that the company is interested because they sent me a follow up email stating they are considring me.

During the interview, they said it will take at least 1 or 2 weeks to know.

Since I am very anxious to get this job, how do I handle this situation get a confirmation if they are still consiering me and will make an offer?

Apr 28th 2009 @ 10:01PM Tabitha

I'm from N.Y. I've done dozens of interviews when job seeking. I don't always do 2nd interviews. If I feel the interviewer wasn't doing their job properly in the first interview I don't bother with a 2nd. I wear a suit, I'm clean, articulate, I show up on time. I ask questions and seem genuinely interested. I do MY part. If they don't do their part the first time or schedule interviews when all the relevant parties are available, I don't always remain interested in the company. I Never do a third interview. I've told interviewers it's no longer an interview process it's a pageant.
I like efficient, no nonsense companies that know what they are looking for. I certainly knew what I was looking for when I found it.

Apr 22nd 2009 @ 4:55PM Danita

Why not do something completely different and fun and earn as much as you like! You can work for yourself and enjoy what you do! Meet lots of great people doing the same thing. Set your own schedule! Travel cheap! Help others do the same and have your own thriving business! Be determined that this year will be so much better than last year! http://www.danita.mydfilive.com

Apr 22nd 2009 @ 6:14PM Cornel

WHATTT "RECESSION"????

There is a "Famous" Quote that goes something like this, "The Major
Key To Your Better "Financial" Future Is YOU!"

If you are Open-Minded, a BIG Thinker and ready to get your "own"
(MBA)Massive-Bank-Account, CHECK THIS OUT!!!

What Do You Have To LOSE?>http://www.casshnurface.com

Apr 23rd 2009 @ 2:48PM Angie

You can specify a salary with this business! No selling, no inventory, no parties. Free step by step training and unlimited support with NO FINANCIAL RISK!

http://www.MomsWhoSucceed.com

Apr 25th 2009 @ 9:00AM Sav

I was never good at barganing my salary...I was a "shrug & ok" type of girl..I too thought you didn't have much of a say in it. You can decide if you'll make $90 an hr or go with what they want you to go with. I chose making my own salary. Get into your own business and make as much as you want. I wanted no one decided my income.

Sav
SavanaSmiles@gmail.com

Apr 27th 2009 @ 12:59PM MARK

Tired of business opportunities that do not deliver what they promise? We have reviewed the top selling programs on the Internet today. Below you will find reviews of the top 3 opportunities that actually work. The key to making money online is knowing how and where to start. Without the right starting point you will waste precious time and a ton of money. The following products guarantee your online success, all you have to do is read them and follow their expert advice so please visit:
www.bestaffordableproductsonline.com

Apr 28th 2009 @ 8:21PM Becky

I am unemployed right now. Too many companies that are offering positions that are similiar to what I was doing are offering $10-12 an hour when I was making a lot more than that when my previous employer let a bunch of us go.
I would hate to have to go backwards in pay to what I was making 10 years ago.

Apr 28th 2009 @ 10:02PM Chad

I am so much in the same boat! Job ops in my field are paying too low for me to make ends meet. They are paying 10-25 grand less for the same job I had before being laid off.

And the employers get defensive and say I should accept what I can get right now. I say to them in return that my bills stay the same where ever I go and they certainly don't lessen just because offered wages are less. Of course, the interview pretty much ends there, but hey,
we have to look out for ourselves. Who else is going to?

So, it makes sense to me to just live off unemployment checks while waiting things out during this horrible economic downturn.

Chad

Apr 28th 2009 @ 10:27PM Shilo

I've been there and I had to learn to leave my ego behind. I had no choice at the time. A small paycheck is better than none. I am very serious, I was working on Capitol Hill in DC and married a man in the military and it really took my ego getting beaten up before I had to realize that I "needed" a check, and then after I got a job was the time to try to find a higher paying one. Hope that helps, and good luck!!!

Apr 28th 2009 @ 8:27PM RUSS

I was tired of many others rich off of my long hours of work. I stopped and started working for myself at home a bout 6 months ago, best thing ever! Many 3 to 4 thousands a month from my computer staying at home. Lots of training and support from a top home online business. Go to http://www.excfo.com and get working for yourself.

Apr 28th 2009 @ 8:49PM Diane Costello

Stop the insanity of job hunting. Why let a company control your future or your salary? The ONLY way to escape from job searching is to be your own boss. A traditional brick and mortar business will OWN you almost as much as a JOB (Just Over Broke!) Your only HOPE is a home based internet business (The internet grows every SECOND!) The paradigm shift has already occurred – this economy is the perfect storm for the home-based business industry.
I can provide you with FREE information to provide you with freedom – time and financial freedom! Go to my site http://www.WealthTheHonestWay.com
Take a minute, fill out your info and I can CHANGE your life forever. Would earning an extra $5,000 to $10,000 or more part-time or full-time change your life? Your dreams CAN come true if you don’t participate in this economy. God Bless!!

Apr 28th 2009 @ 9:07PM Tony

I have just been introduced to a new business opportunity and I’m thinking you might be interested. The two major components are advertising and customer generation for small businesses; and, IPTV (technology to broadcast Television using the internet). You don't have to pay for the advertising until we bring you customers and they pay you first.

The business is headquartered in Atlanta and is scheduled to launch in May (all major US cities) so you will finally have a chance to be a part of something that is truly at the ground floor. This business will also compliment any MLM that you are currently involved in. It will be worth the 1 1/2-hours of your time to check it out.

Our meetings are held every Sunday at 3:00 pm and Monday and Thursdays at 7:00 pm. The location is near 316 (85 North) and Sugarloaf Parkway.

Contact me as soon as possible for directions and to reserve a presentation slot. Sales personnel who are feeling the pains of a slow economy need to check this opportunity out-it's HUGE

PSV is almost nothing with no products to buy. Pay structure is uni-level; paying seven (7) levels equally.

Tony Fontana

404-427-0672

Apr 29th 2009 @ 9:44PM JK

WOULDN'T IT BE NICE NOT TO HAVE TO WORRY ABOUT TALKING TO YOUR BOSS ABOUT SALARY OR ANYTHING FOR THAT MATTER? GET YOUR OWN BUSINESS AND YOU WON'T HAVE TO. MAKE THE MONEY OF YOUR DREAMS. I AM....COME JOIN ME.
HTTP://WWW.MEYEVISION.INFO

Apr 28th 2009 @ 10:50PM Paula

After having a good salary for 20+ years they think they can just lay you off!! Never again...started working from home and making more than they would like to know. If you are really serious about making big money from home and not having to worry about kissing any @ss then go to http://www.freeofyourboss.com if you are serious...it take work, a few hours a day, but you can make a few extra Thousand a month. Don't let someone else decide your future!

Apr 28th 2009 @ 11:09PM Renee

Is there any good advise to finding a job? Not a work from home scam?! I am looking for an administrative position and have good experience. Its hard to get past the emailing of resumes to get in front of someone. If I get that chance I know I will make a lasting impression. Anyone?

Thanks,
Renee

Apr 28th 2009 @ 11:07PM otrpu

All above are spam

Apr 29th 2009 @ 9:53PM JK

Not even close. just because the business is online does not mean it is bad. do your research before you judge. I am making a nice living. It is that kind of attitude that will keep you from achieving what you want.